Reviews for papilo
All reviews for this package from team members (across all versions).
| Reviewer | Version | Allocated | Started | Status | Completed | Comment | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| siretart | 3.0.0+ds-1 | 5 hours ago | 5 hours ago | rejected | 2 hours ago | Hi, I have to reject this package because papilo_3.0.0+ds-1 contains licensing contradictions and non-free headers, which violate the DFSG. While debian/copyright and the root LICENSE file claim the software is licensed under Apache-2.0, several files in the source tree still carry the non-free "ZIB Academic License" headers. This license is not DFSG-compliant as it restricts use to academic purposes and prohibits commercial redistribution. Specific examples of problematic headers: 1. check/check.sh (Lines 8-12): * SCIP is distributed under the terms of the ZIB Academic License. * You should have received a copy of the ZIB Academic License * along with SCIP; see the file COPYING. If not email to scip@zib.de. 2. Makefile (Lines 8-12): * SCIP is distributed under the terms of the ZIB Academic License. * You should have received a copy of the ZIB Academic License * along with SCIP; see the file COPYING. If not email to scip@zib.de. These headers appear in at least 12 files, including: - ./check/evalcheck_cluster.sh - ./check/configuration_logfiles.sh - ./check/waitcluster.sh - ./check/check.sh - ./check/run.sh - ./check/check_cluster.sh - ./check/configuration_solufile.sh - ./check/configuration_set.sh - ./check/configuration_cluster.sh - ./check/wakeup-slurm - ./Makefile - ./make/make.detecthost Since debian/copyright (Files: *) incorrectly identifies these files as Apache-2.0 without addressing the explicit non-free headers, the package cannot be accepted into main in its current state. Please ensure all file headers are updated by upstream or patched to accurately reflect the DFSG-free license before re-uploading. Additionally, several Find*.cmake modules (e.g., FindGLOP.cmake, FindGMP.cmake, FindGUROBI.cmake) are missing from debian/copyright. -rt | View |