DFSG NEW Queue

DFSG, Licensing & New Packages Team

med-fichier 6.0.1+repack-1

Package Information

DescriptionDevelopment files for libmed

MED-fichier (Modélisation et Echanges de Données, in English Modelisation and Data Exchange) is a library to store and exchange meshed data or computation results. It uses the HDF5 file format to store the data.

MaintainerDebian Science Maintainers <debian-science-maintainers@lists.alioth.debian.org>
Changed ByNico Della Torre <nicoz91@ubuntu.com>
Sponsortille@debian.org
Distributionunstable
Architectureany all
VCSgit: https://salsa.debian.org/science-team/med-fichier.git (browse)
Popcon Installs4812
Binary NEWYes (new binary packages of a source already in sid)
Trackerhttps://tracker.debian.org/pkg/med-fichier
Uploaded3 hours ago

Potential Library Transition

This binary NEW upload drops binary packages that currently have reverse dependencies in unstable. A library transition may need to be coordinated with the Release Team before accepting this package.

Dropped BinaryRdeps in unstable
libmedc11t641: libfreecad-python3

The maintainer says no transition is needed and asked us to review anyway.

There is just one single rdep which can transition directly in unstable

— tille, 1 hour ago

New Package Report

.changes◂
Changed-ByNico Della Torre <nicoz91@ubuntu.com>
Architecturesource amd64 all
Distributionunstable
DateTue, 17 Nov 2026 12:05:37 +0100
Sourcemed-fichier
Version6.0.1+repack-1
Changelog◂
med-fichier (6.0.1+repack-1) unstable; urgency=medium
 .
   * Team upload.
   * New upstream release.
   * d/watch: Convert to version 5 and point to the new upstream
     location.
   * Rename library packages for the SONAME bump: libmed11 -> libmed14,
     libmedc11t64 -> libmedc14.
   * Drop patches applied upstream: check_hdf5, fix-stack-smashing-in-test,
     fix-tests, incompatible-pointer-types, swig-4.3, tests-fix-diff-filters.
   * Replace hdf5-1.14 and relax-hdf5-version-check with hdf5-2.patch:
     allow building with HDF5 2.x, the file format stays pinned to 1.14.
   * d/rules: Build with the HDF5 1.14 API.
   * d/rules: Link with the MPI libraries, needed by the parallel tests.
   * Add h5perf-optional.patch: h5perf is not shipped by Debian HDF5.
   * Refresh remaining patches
.dsc◂
Priorityoptional
Componentmain
Package-Listlibmed-dev deb libdevel optional arch=any
libmed-doc deb doc optional arch=all
libmed-tools deb science optional arch=any
libmed14 deb libs optional arch=any
libmedc-dev deb libdevel optional arch=any
libmedc14 deb libs optional arch=any
libmedimport-dev deb libdevel optional arch=any
libmedimport0v5 deb libs optional arch=any
python3-med deb python optional arch=any
Sectionlibdevel
debian/copyright◂
Format: https://www.debian.org/doc/packaging-manuals/copyright-format/1.0/
Upstream-Contact: EDF R&D, Eric Fayolle <eric.fayolle@edf.fr>, Vincent Lefebvre <vincent.lefebvre@edf.fr>
Source: http://www.salome-platform.org/downloads/current-version

Files: *
Copyright: Copyright (C) 1999-2018 EDF R&D
License: LGPL-3+
 This program is free software; you can redistribute it and/or modify
 it under the terms of the GNU Lesser General Public License
 as published by the Free Software Foundation, either version 3 of the
 license, or (at your option) any later version.
 .
 On Debian GNU/Linux systems, the complete text of the GNU Lesser General
 Public License can be found in `/usr/share/common-licenses/LGPL-3'

Files: debian/*
Copyright: Copyright (C) 2009 Aurelien Jarno <aurel32@debian.org>
           Copyright (C) 2010-2011 Adam C Powell IV <hazelsct@debian.org>
           Copyright (C) 2013 Sergei Golovan <sgolovan@nes.ru>
           Copyright (C) 2013-2014 Christophe Trophime <christrophime@googlemail.com>
           Copyright (C) 2014 Adam Conrad <adconrad@ubuntu.com>
                              Arthur Marble <arthur@info9.net>
           Copyright (C) 2013-2018 Anton Gladky <gladk@debian.org>
           Copyright (C) 2014, 2016-2018 Gilles Filippini <pini@debian.org>
License: LGPL-2.1
 This program is free software; you can redistribute it and/or modify
 it under the terms of the GNU Lesser General Public License
 version 2.1 as published by the Free Software Foundation;
 .
 On Debian GNU/Linux systems, the complete text of the GNU Lesser General
 Public License can be found in `/usr/share/common-licenses/LGPL-2.1'

DFSG Assistant LLM REVIEW 2 blocker, 1 important, 2 minor

This is an LLM based review using a Debian Inference based workflow. It was not written by a member of the DFSG team and has not been checked by one. It is not a decision on the package: it may be wrong, and it may have missed things.

Reviewed 1 hour ago.

Report◂

DFSG NEW review for med-fichier version 6.0.1+repack-1

Summary

  • Licensing is DFSG-compliant and debian/copyright is accurate: No
  • Packaging is of good quality: No
  • Issues: 2 blocker, 1 important, 2 minor
  • debian/watch: version 5
  • debian/copyright: machine-readable
  • Scan before the review: nothing found

Licensing

The upstream code is LGPL-3+ and DFSG-free, but debian/copyright does not describe it accurately. It names only EDF R&D, although every compiled source file is copyright 'EDF R&D, CEA/DEN' (1999-2025). The catch-all Files: * stanza also labels third-party build files as LGPL-3+ although they are GPL-2+/GPL-3+, LGPL-2.1 or MIT, and it reproduces neither the MIT notice nor the authors of the autotools/CMake helper files or of the recent Debian work.

Packaging

The packaging is largely careful: correct SONAMEs (libmed14/libmedc14), a proper package split, DEP-3 headers on the new patches, autopkgtests and a consistent doc-base path. But libmed-dev silently drops the installed Fortran include files med_parameter.hf, med.hf77 and med.hf90, which breaks 'include "med.hf"' for its users; debhelper compat 11's silent dh_missing is why the build does not notice.

Issues

blocker licensing 1. debian/copyright omits CEA/DEN, co-holder of every compiled source file ◂
  • Files: debian/copyright:6, src/ci/MEDchampCr.c:3, include/med.h.in:4, src/2.3.6/cfi/famcf.c:3
  • Basis: checked, in the package or with a reference tool
  • Evidence: debian/copyright:6: Copyright: Copyright (C) 1999-2018 EDF R&D, while src/ci/MEDchampCr.c:3 and include/med.h.in:4 say COPYRIGHT (C) 1999 - 2025 EDF R&D, CEA/DEN
  • Problem: CEA/DEN is a second copyright holder, named in about 1150 C, C++, Fortran, SWIG and installed header files, all compiled into libmed14, libmedc14, libmed-tools and python3-med. Debian Policy 2.3 requires the copyright notices of compiled files in debian/copyright when the licence requires them to be kept, as LGPL-3+ does; the file never mentions CEA/DEN, and its year range is also seven years stale (2018 vs 2025).
  • Fix: Name both holders in the Files: * stanza, e.g. Copyright: Copyright (C) 1999-2025 EDF R&D and Copyright: Copyright (C) 1999-2025 CEA/DEN (or one line listing both).
blocker licensing 2. Files: * mislabels third-party config/ files as LGPL-3+ though they are GPL-2+/GPL-3+, LGPL-2.1 and MIT ◂
  • Files: debian/copyright:5-13, config/install-sh:10-27, config/ax_pkg_swig.m4:41-52, config/ax_prog_cc_mpi.m4:49-63, config/config.guess:8-27, config/compile:10-22, config/ltmain.sh:12-23, config/cmake_files/FindMedfileHDF5.cmake:1-8, config/ax_absolute_header.m4:18-24, config/ax_compare_version.m4:72-79
  • Basis: checked, in the package or with a reference tool
  • Evidence: config/install-sh:10,17: Copyright (C) 1994 X Consortium / Permission is hereby granted, free of charge, ...; config/ax_pkg_swig.m4:44: under the terms of the GNU General Public License ... version 2 ... or (at your option) any later version; config/ax_prog_cc_mpi.m4:51: version 3 of the License, or (at your option) any later version; config/config.guess:8: GPL-3+ with the same distribution terms ... exception; config/cmake_files/FindMedfileHDF5.cmake:4: under the terms of the GNU Lesser General Public License ... version 2.1 of the License; config/ax_absolute_header.m4: all-permissive
  • Problem: Files: * claims LGPL-3+ for the whole tree, which is wrong for these files. The Autoconf/libtool exceptions let the generated configure script and the package be distributed under the project's terms; they do not relicense the .m4 files or the helper scripts themselves, which remain GPL-2+/GPL-3+. install-sh is MIT/X11, whose permission notice is not in /usr/share/common-licenses and is not reproduced in debian/copyright, and the cmake_files are LGPL-2.1. The source package is distributed with a copyright file that misstates their licences, and a permissive notice that its licence requires to be kept is missing.
  • Fix: Add Files stanzas with stand-alone License paragraphs: GPL-2+ with the Autoconf exception for ax_pkg_swig.m4 and config/{compile,depcomp,missing,py-compile} and ltmain.sh/libtool.m4 (pointer to /usr/share/common-licenses/GPL-2); GPL-3+ with the Autoconf exception for config/{config.guess,config.sub} and the ax_prog__mpi.m4/ax_python_devel.m4/ax_swig_python.m4 macros (GPL-3); LGPL-2.1 for config/cmake_files/; the all-permissive text for ax_absolute_header.m4 and ax_compare_version.m4; and the full MIT/X11 notice of config/install-sh.
important packaging 3. libmed-dev drops med_parameter.hf, med.hf77 and med.hf90, breaking the installed Fortran interface ◂
  • Files: debian/libmed-dev.install:1-4, include/med.hf:1, include/med.hf77:1, include/med.hf90:1, include/Makefile.am:2, include/Makefile.am:10, python/Makefile.am:24
  • Basis: checked, in the package or with a reference tool
  • Evidence: include/med.hf:1: include "med_parameter.hf"; include/Makefile.am:2: include_HEADERS = med.hf med.hf77 med.hf90 med_proto.h ...; include/Makefile.am:10: nodist_include_HEADERS = med.h med_utils.h med_parameter.hf; debian/libmed-dev.install lists only usr/include/2.3.6/med.hf and usr/include/med.hf
  • Problem: make install puts /usr/include/med_parameter.hf, med.hf77 and med.hf90 in debian/tmp, and python/Makefile.am's swig_DATA puts the SWIG interfaces in /usr/include/swig, but no package's .install picks any of them up. At debhelper compat 11 dh_missing silently does nothing, so the build succeeds with the files dropped. A Fortran user of libmed-dev doing include 'med.hf' or include 'med.hf90' then fails because med_parameter.hf is absent; the in-tree tests do not catch it because they compile against the source include/ directory.
  • Fix: Add usr/include/med_parameter.hf, usr/include/med.hf77 and usr/include/med.hf90 to debian/libmed-dev.install (and usr/include/swig if the SWIG interfaces should be shipped); consider moving to compat 13 or passing --fail-missing to dh_missing so future uninstalled upstream files are reported.
minor licensing 4. debian/copyright names none of the autotools, Autoconf-Archive or CMake file holders ◂
  • Files: debian/copyright:5, config/install-sh:10, config/config.guess:2, config/ax_prog_cc_mpi.m4:47, config/ax_python_devel.m4:36-42, config/ax_pkg_swig.m4:34-38, config/ltmain.sh:75, config/cmake_files/deprecated/FindHDF5.cmake:1-4
  • Basis: checked, in the package or with a reference tool
  • Evidence: Copyright (C) 1994 X Consortium (install-sh); Copyright 1992-2024 Free Software Foundation, Inc. (config.guess); Copyright (c) 2010,2011 Olaf Lenz; Copyright (c) 2009 Sebastian Huber, Alan W. Irwin, Rafael Laboissiere, Andrew Collier, Matteo Settenvini, Horst Knorr, Daniel Mullner; Copyright (c) 2009 Derek Price, Rhys Ulerich; Copyright (c) 2008 Tim Toolan; Bootstrap Authors (ltmain.sh); Copyright (C) 2003-2007 OPEN CASCADE, EADS/CCR, LIP6, CEA/DEN, CEDRAT, EDF R&D, LEG, PRINCIPIA R&D, BUREAU VERITAS (FindHDF5.cmake)
  • Problem: Debian Policy 2.3 does not require these notices in debian/copyright: every one of these files is build machinery (configure/aclocal/Makefile.in, the autotools helper scripts, the Autoconf-Archive macros) or a CMake helper module not used by this packaging, none is installed into a binary package, and each is shipped as plain text with its notice intact. The DFSG team nevertheless expects debian/copyright to account for the whole source tree.
  • Fix: Add Files stanzas for config/* and config/cmake_files/* naming these holders, together with the licences from the previous issue.
minor licensing 5. debian/* stanza omits Nico Della Torre, Tobias Frost and Thomas Moulard ◂
  • Files: debian/copyright:16-27, debian/patches/hdf5-2.patch:4, debian/patches/fix-ftbfs-python.patch:6, debian/tests/build1:3-4, debian/tests/build2:3-4
  • Basis: checked, in the package or with a reference tool
  • Evidence: Author: Nico Della Torre <nicoz91@ubuntu.com> in hdf5-2.patch, h5perf-optional.patch and python-avoid-version.patch; Author: Tobias Frost <tobi@debian.org> in fix-ftbfs-python.patch; # (C) 2013 Thomas Moulard in debian/tests/build1 and build2
  • Problem: The debian/* Copyright list ends with the 2018 maintainers and does not name the authors of this upload's patches or of the test scripts. Debian Policy 2.3 does not require it: debian/* is not shipped in any binary package, and these are plain-text files carrying their own notices. It still leaves debian/copyright incomplete.
  • Fix: Add the missing holders, at least Copyright (C) 2026 Nico Della Torre, Copyright (C) 2026 Tobias Frost and Copyright (C) 2013 Thomas Moulard, to the debian/* stanza.
Verified ◂
  • Read every file under debian/ in full: control, rules, changelog (first entry and history), copyright, all .install files, docs, libmed-doc.doc-base, source/format, tests/control, tests/build1 and build2, orig-tar.sh, patches/series and all seven patches.
  • The 15 holders dfsg-author-check lists are all in config/ build machinery (aclocal.m4, configure, Makefile.in, config.guess/sub, compile, depcomp, install-sh, missing, py-compile, ltmain.sh, config/*.m4) and in config/cmake_files/; none is installed into a binary package and each keeps its notice in the file (covered by the two copyright issues above).
  • All ~1150 C/C++/Fortran/SWIG sources, tools and installed headers carry the same LGPL-3+ header 'COPYRIGHT (C) 1999 - 2025 EDF R&D, CEA/DEN'; no other holder appears outside the build files.
  • python/_wrap.cc, python/.py and python/swig_runtime.h are SWIG 4.3.0 output without a separate copyright notice; debian/rules deletes and regenerates the wrappers from python/*.i (my_configure_common), so the preferred form for modification is present.
  • doc/ contains only the MED documentation: hand-written French HTML sources, the gif/jpg/png/svg figures, doxygen sources, and doc/odt/MEDmeshnEntity.html as an HTML export; no separate holder or licence was found. The repack removed the generated doxygen output (debian/orig-tar.sh).
  • tests/ .med files are binary test fixtures checked in as reference data, not built artifacts.
  • No built binaries, libraries, PDFs or archives are in the tree (glob for a/so/o/lo/la/pyc/pdf/zip/tgz returned nothing), and grep found no non-commercial, no-modification, 'All rights reserved' or other non-free wording, and no SPDX identifiers.
  • The m4/Makefile.am patches take effect: at compat 11 debhelper's sequencer adds dh_autoreconf by default (SequencerUtil.pm line 392), and debhelper depends on dh-autoreconf, so patched config/med_check_hdf5.m4 and python/Makefile.am are regenerated before configure; hdf5 2.2.0 is in unstable, so hdf5-2.patch is needed.
  • Package names match the SONAME: configure.ac sets MED_LIBTOOL_MAJ=14, so libmed14/libmedc14 are correct; Standards-Version 4.7.4 matches the reviewing system's Policy 4.7.x.
  • debian/libmed-doc.doc-base's /usr/share/doc/libmed-doc/med/index.html matches docdir=/usr/share/doc/med (AC_INIT package name 'med') followed by dh_install's cp -a of the matched directory into /usr/share/doc/libmed-doc (read /usr/bin/dh_install).
  • Autopkgtests: debian/tests/build1/build2 compile and run a C program against libmedc-dev; mpicc comes via libmedc-dev -> libhdf5-mpi-dev -> mpi-default-dev, and Testsuite: autopkgtest-pkg-python matches the med package installed in /usr/lib/python3/dist-packages/med.
  • All glob/grep calls used gitignore:false; .pc/ and the absent debian/cargo-checksum.json were left out.
  • uscan found the packaged version as the newest upstream release (upstream 6.0.1, packaged 6.0.1+repack).
  • Every pointer of debian/copyright to /usr/share/common-licenses names a file that is there (LGPL-2.1, LGPL-3).
Not confirmed ◂
  • I could not build the package or inspect .deb contents; the missing-header finding rests on the upstream install rules, the complete set of debian/*.install files and debhelper's compat-11 dh_missing behaviour, not on a built package.
Proposed changes ◂

None.

Uploader's response to the LLM review

The review is right on all points; fixed in https://salsa.debian.org/science-team/med-fichier/-/merge_requests/5 and will be in -2, uploaded right after acceptance.

— Nico Della Torre (nicoz), 1 hour ago

Back to Dashboard | View all reviews for this package